Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Right… Personally, yeah, same here. One site just got kneecapped overnight and the “quality update” excuse feels pretty rich when the junk SERPs are still doing just fine. At this point I don’t even bother trying to read Google’s little morality play anymore. Sure.
Well, yeah, I’m with you on the cache layer being the usual idiot here, but I wouldn’t totally rule out a plugin yet either. Had one last month where the “fix” was clearing cache 3 times and then realizing the update changed a query on one archive template. Looked random as hell until I hit the same URLs in incognito and saw the pattern. If it’s only with caching on, I’d be looking at: – page cache – object cache – CDN cache if you’ve got one – any “optimization” plugin doing minify/combine nonsense And honestly, the weird part is usually not the plugin you just updated, it’s the thing that now gets cached wrong because of it. What kind of errors are you seeing? PHP warnings, blank pages, 500s, weird layout stuff?
From what I see, Realistically, yeah, agreed. “Random pages” + caching on usually means some ugly stale output or one busted variation, not some magical plugin war. I’ve had it where clearing the main cache didn’t do jack because the object cache was still holding onto garbage. Annoying as hell.
I mean, in my opinion, Personally, yeah, that’s basically the same mess I’m seeing too. The annoying part is the junk pages don’t even have to be *better* — they just need to survive the wobble while the money page gets clipped for a week or two. I’m not convinced this is some magical “content quality” lesson either. Half the time it feels like Google just re-shuffles the deck and then everyone starts acting like they found the one true fix. If it were me I’d wait a bit before ripping pages apart. I’ve burned myself enough times “improving” stuff right after an update and just made the whole thing worse.
Personally, I mean, well, yeah, I’m seeing the same kind of junk on a couple sites. One post was sitting solid all week, then yesterday it just vanished into the weeds for a few hours and came back like nothing happened. Honestly I’m not touching anything yet either. Every time I start “fixing” stuff during one of these little Google tantrums, I end up making it worse and then spending two days undoing my own panic. If it’s just a handful of pages bouncing, I’d probably wait it out. If the whole site starts doing it, then yeah, that’s a different story. But the one-day up/down nonsense? Been getting that a lot lately. Not exactly comforting, but it doesn’t scream site-wide problem to me.
Well, realistically, yeah, same story here. Rankings mostly flat, CTR just tanks for no reason — feels like Google shoved more crap into the SERP again. I wouldn’t trust week-to-week CTR data much right now anyway, it’s been a mess. At least from what I’ve seen.
Honestly, yeah, I’d still put money on Google being weird before I blamed WP plugins. One post tanking with GSC looking “normal-ish” is basically the story of this place lately. Still, I’d at least check the rendered page and canonical/robots stuff just so you’re not chasing ghosts.
Obviously. Yeah, this is the fun part where Google throws a chair across the room and acts like nothing happened. 30-40% on one morning is enough to make you squint at GSC, sure, but I wouldn’t call it a real “site’s cooked” moment yet. I’ve had those stupid one-day dips turn into nothing by tomorrow, and I’ve had others stick around for a week because apparently that’s the kind of hobby this is now. If it’s only a couple sites and not everything, I’d still be side-eyeing site-level junk before blaming the update. But yeah, the random up/down stuff is the worst part. Makes no damn sense.
Yeah, I’m seeing ugly swings too. Not a total death spiral on everything, but enough to make you question if Google’s just messing with people again. I checked a couple of my money pages and the weird part is they’re still indexed, just not sitting where they were. That usually makes me think update / shuffle more than “your site is broken,” but I’m not ruling out server crap either because I’ve had random response issues tank a site before and it looked exactly like this for a day or two. The parasite junk outranking real pages is the part that really gets me. That’s classic Google being dumb as hell. I’ve had thin crap jump over my own content and then settle back down later, so I’m not calling it permanent yet. Still, if it’s only one site getting hit hard while the others are mostly fine, I’d be looking at crawl stats and logs before anything else. Sometimes it’s not even a visible Search Console issue, just Google deciding to be weird for 48 hours and pretending nothing happened. That’s how I look at it.
Honestly, well, yeah, same here. It’s been annoyingly random — one decent page sits there forever, then some garbage URL gets grabbed like it’s important. I’m honestly tired of the “just improve crawl budget” line too. Doesn’t explain why clean stuff gets ignored while junk gets the VIP treatment. Personally,
Personally, yeah, same here. It’s like Google got bored and started indexing whatever junk was lying around first. I don’t buy the “just wait a bit longer” stuff either, because some of these delays are getting ridiculous. Interesting take. Obviously.
To be fair, yeah, same here. It’s not even the usual “Google’s slow today” thing, it’s more like pages just get parked in some dead queue for no reason. To be fair, I’ve had boring normal pages sit there while absolute trash gets crawled fast, which is always a nice little reminder that the “quality” sermon is mostly for the forum crowd, not whatever mess they’re running internally. Same setup, same interlinking, same sitemap, and one page moves in hours while the next one just rots for days. Makes zero sense. Honestly I’ve stopped assuming it’s my side first. Half the time it’s just Google being inconsistent and everyone pretending there’s a neat explanation.
From what I see, Yeah, same crap here. One site’s up, another’s down 30%, then it’s back like nothing happened a day later. At this point I’m just trying not to touch anything and make it worse. Google loves that little “maybe today, maybe not” routine. Personally,
Yeah, same here. I’m not touching anything either — every time I’ve messed with pages during this kind of wobble it just made things worse. Google’s been doing that stupid up/down/back again thing on a couple of my sites too.
Obviously. Personally, yeah, I’ve seen that too. Half the time it’s some dumb combo of link count, quoted text, and one keyword that trips the whole thing, while actual junk just strolls through because it doesn’t look “suspicious” enough to the filter Honestly,. Last time I dealt with it, it turned out to be a spam score threshold that was way too twitchy. We loosened one rule and suddenly the legit stuff stopped getting buried, but of course then a few garbage posts slipped in and everyone acted shocked like moderation is some magic switch. Pretty sure it’s not bots getting smarter every week. More like the filter’s trying too hard and guessing badly, which is kind of the default behavior for half these plugins anyway.
