Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Yeah, same here. Not a total faceplant, just enough nonsense to make the charts look haunted for a couple days. I’ve got one site that’s basically flat, another that took a hit on random deeper pages, and nothing obvious changed on either. So I’m not rushing to start “optimizing” anything yet. Google’s just doing its usual little mood swing thing.
Yeah, I’ve seen it. It’s especially annoying when the “winner” is some garbage forum thread from 2019 that barely answers anything, while the actual page has the exact wording and decent structure. Feels like the system is grabbing whatever’s easiest to pattern-match, not what’s actually useful. And honestly, I don’t buy the “just make better content” line anymore. We’ve had pages that were solid, indexed fine, linked fine, and still got skipped. So yeah, semantic matching seems to be doing a lot more of the heavy lifting than people want to admit.
Yeah, I’m seeing the same kind of garbage on one of mine. One site barely moved, the other got shoved around for a handful of pages/queries and GSC looks like a drunk spreadsheet. Impressions hanging there while clicks go flat usually means the rankings aren’t actually “stable,” they’re just bouncing in a way GSC doesn’t make obvious. I’d check the landing pages first, not the whole site. Half the time it’s one template, one intent shift, or some SERP feature crowding out clicks. If it’s still doing it after a week, then I’d…
In my opinion, Personally, yeah, same here. Not a flood, just that annoying steady trickle of junk that somehow looks “normal” for about 5 minutes. The half-real ones are the worst, like Den said.
In my opinion, yeah, I’ve seen that too. Not a full-on flood, but enough that you notice it every day, which is always the annoying part. On a couple sites it’s been mostly signup junk, not so much comments, which makes me think it’s just some bot batch shifting around again rather than anything magical in the update. I’d still check whether the requests are coming from the same IPs / user agents as before. If it’s all new garbage, that’s one thing. If it’s the same old trash with a different timing, then it’s most likely just a wave. Also wouldn’t shock me if some plugin got a little looser after the update and made the forms easier to hit. Happens more than people want to admit.
Usually, yeah, I’d still put the plugin update near the top of the list. I’ve had cache plugins do some dumb stuff where the site *looked* fine, but Google was clearly seeing different output, or the sitemap/canonical stuff got weird after an update. SEO plugins can be just as annoying if they quietly flip a setting or start outputting junk. If impressions dropped too, that makes me less interested in the “just a normal Google shuffle” excuse. That usually doesn’t line up that neatly with a plugin update.
Personally, Yeah, that’s been my experience too. Stuff that should be a no-brainer just sits there like it’s waiting for permission from some intern at Google. And the annoying part is it’s not even consistent enough to troubleshoot cleanly. Same site, same crawl patterns, one URL flies through, another just languishes for days for no obvious reason. I’ve had it happen on sites with solid internal linking and clean sitemaps, so I’m not buying the usual “must be your content” lecture either. Personally,
Honestly, In my opinion, yep, same here. It’s not even the usual “slow but steady” thing anymore, it’s just random as hell. I’ve had boring little pages sit there for days while some dumb junk URL gets picked up first. Makes the whole “just improve the content” line sound even more ridiculous than usual.
Yeah, seeing the same kind of nonsense here. One client site was basically fine for months, then this week it’s doing the yo-yo thing on a few core pages for no obvious reason. Honestly I don’t buy the “just wait and improve content” line every time. Sometimes it’s just Google being twitchy, or some weird re-eval after an update, and you’re stuck watching positions bounce around for no good reason. That’s how I look at it.
In my opinion, Usually, from what I’ve seen, yeah, it’s not just you. I’ve been seeing more of that stupid “works fine until you touch cache / cron / AJAX” nonsense too. And yeah, the “disable one by one” crowd acts like that’s some brilliant insight. Sometimes it’s useful, sure, but half the time the breakage only shows up after an update or a cache purge, so you’re basically chasing ghosts.
Yeah, same here. Not really seeing a clean “your site is dead” pattern, more like Google just moved the goalposts again and buried the click under more junk. If impressions are still there, I’d be looking at SERPs and query mix before blaming the page.
From what I’ve seen, yeah, it’s been weird as hell. I’ve had pages crawl clean and then just sit there with no movement, while some trashy competitor page gets indexed like it paid for priority.
Yeah, that tracks. I’ve had a couple sites do the exact same dumb little staircase thing this week — looks like nothing, then suddenly a nosedive, then it crawls back like it never happened. And yeah, “just keep publishing quality content” is such useless boilerplate at this point. If it was that simple, half the forum wouldn’t be here losing their minds every month. I’d still check the boring stuff first though — Search Console, crawl stats, any weird canonical/indexing nonsense, and whether one section got hit harder than the rest. Half the time it’s not even the content, it’s Google being weird about. That’s been my experience anyway.
In my opinion, Yep, seen plenty of it. And honestly the “it’s your theme” crowd usually hasn’t looked past the first obvious thing. The annoying part is when it’s some dumb interaction between cache + JS defer + a plugin update and it only blows up after a purge or when a cron runs. Fun stuff. I’ve had a “harmless” SEO plugin start messing with admin-ajax before, so yeah, not exactly rare.
Yep, same here on a couple sites. Not the “everything tanked” kind of mess, just clicks getting weird while impressions hang around like nothing happened. Feels like one of those Google weeks where the numbers look almost normal until you actually look at leads and traffic quality. Annoying as hell. That’s been my experience anyway.