Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Yeah, I’ve had the same crap this week. One page drops for no reason, another one bounces back like nothing happened — makes zero sense. At this point I’m not even assuming it’s “my site” unless it stays bad for more than a week. Google’s just doing its usual little tantrum. At least lately.
Yeah, I’ve had that too. “Fix” one thing and Google acts like you kicked over the table for a week. Half the time it does settle, but half the time that’s just forum folklore people repeat because they don’t want to admit the page was shaky already. Interesting take. Okay then.
Interesting take. Obviously. Yeah, I’ve seen it too, and honestly I don’t buy the “just wait” line half the time. Sometimes it really is Google doing that dumb little re-crawl / re-score wobble, but other times the page was already kind of held together with duct tape and the indexing fix just made the problems show up. I’ve had pages get picked up, then lose impressions for a few days, then come back… and I’ve had others just keep bleeding traffic because the page was never that strong to begin with. What’s annoying is it never looks clean. You fix one thing and Google acts like you kicked a hornet nest. Then everyone on here starts acting like it’s all normal and temporary, which is easy to say when it’s not your traffic tanking. If it’s only a short dip, fine. If it’s still sliding after a week or two, I’d stop blaming indexing and start looking at whether the page actually deserves to rank. Which, yeah, sucks, but Google’s been pretty good at making that obvious lately.
Kind of feels like yeah, same garbage here. I’ve got a couple pages that usually move in 24-48 hours and lately they’re just sitting there doing the dead fish thing for no obvious reason. What’s annoying is it’s not even consistent site to site. One niche site gets stuff in, another one with basically the same setup gets ignored for days. So the whole “just improve the content” answer is useless, honestly. I’ve had *some* luck getting stuff picked up by pushing it harder through internal links and making sure it’s not orphaned, but even that feels hit or miss. Feels more like Google’s just in one of those moods where it decides a page exists when it feels like it. At least lately.
Obviously. In my opinion, yeah, that’s been happening a lot. The annoying part is Google seems totally happy to index junk fast and then just… do nothing with it. Like thanks for the participation trophy, I guess. I wouldn’t trust the “indexed means it’s fine” crowd on this one. If older pages are fine and new ones just get a tiny blip then die, it usually feels more like site/section trust than some magical content flaw. Which is great if you enjoy watching affiliate pages rot in real time.
Honestly, Yeah, pretty much. I’ve got one site that did a weird little moonshot for no obvious reason and another that got smacked after a “cleanup” that was supposed to help Well,. At this point I don’t even buy the clean quality talk unless there’s a pattern over a few weeks. Half the time it feels like Google’s just shuffling stuff around and we’re all trying to read tea leaves. Just my experience.
Well, yeah, I’m seeing the same crap. What’s been driving me nuts is it’s not even consistent site to site. One domain will get a half-decent page picked up in a day, then another one with the same setup just sits there for ages like it’s been forgotten. And then, like you said, some junk page with basically no effort gets indexed stupid fast. I’ve stopped assuming it’s my setup unless there’s an actual crawl issue or no internal links. Even then… sometimes it still feels like Google just does whatever it wants for a week and then changes its mind. I had one affiliate page finally get indexed after 4-5 days, then it dropped hard and never really recovered. No obvious change on my end. Honestly feels more like the usual indexing roulette than anything new. I’m not even bothering to tweak stuff every time anymore because half the time it just makes no difference.
Okay then. From what I’ve seen, right… Yeah, same here. Two sites I’m watching took a hit and nothing obvious changed, which is always fun when clients want a neat little reason. Feels like another one of those “we tweaked the soup” weeks.
Yep, same here. Two sites down, one stupid little page is somehow “winning,” which is classic Google nonsense. Kind of feels like I’m not touching anything yet either. Last time I chased one of these swings I just made a bad week into a worse one. Personally,
Well, yeah, I’m seeing it too. Not a total wipeout, just that stupid “why is *this* page moving and not the one I actually care about?” nonsense. One site’s down around 20-25% and another one’s weirdly up, which usually means nothing good and everything’s unstable. I’m basically just letting it sit for now because every time I’ve tried to “fix” stuff mid-mess I end up making it worse. Google really does love pretending this is all normal though. Total. Just my experience.
Yeah, same here. Not enough to scream “update! I mean,” or whatever, but it’s definitely doing that annoying Google thing where the logs look drunk. The junk URL obsession is the part I hate most. Feels like it always finds some stupid trash path to waste time on, then the pages you actually care about get treated like they’re optional. Right…
Obviously. From what I’ve seen, right… Yeah, I’ve seen that exact “everything’s fine except it isn’t” mess after updates. Usually it’s one of those stupid combo problems where the plugin itself isn’t *broken* but it changed something tiny and now cache/minify/admin assets are tripping over each other. Had one site where the frontend looked mostly okay, but wp-admin was acting drunk until I killed the optimization plugin for a bit. Of course it wasn’t the one I expected. If you already rolled one back and it only helped a little, I’d be looking at anything touching cache, JS/CSS combine, lazy load, or “performance” crap first. Those are always the ones that pretend they’re helping while quietly making the site miserable. Also wouldn’t totally dismiss the host, but if the timing lines up with plugin updates, that’s usually where I’d put my money. Host issues don’t normally show up as “random layout weirdness” unless something’s already poking at files on the plugin side.
Sure. To be fair, yeah, a bit. Nothing dramatic, but the crawl looks kinda sloppy lately. I’ve got one site where Googlebot’s chewing through old junk like it’s on a mission, then acting allergic to updated pages. Classic Google nonsense, honestly.
Yeah, I wouldn’t call that a win either. I’ve had the same dumb pattern where GSC looks “busy” for a couple days and then the actual clicks go sideways like Google just kicked the wrong door in. Half the time it’s some junk variant or thin page getting attention first, like crawl_void said, but I’m not convinced it’s always that neat. Sometimes it just feels like the whole thing gets twitchy for no reason and you’re stuck staring at charts like an idiot. That’s how I look at it.
Well, interesting take. Yeah, I’m not buying “just a wobble” for every little drop either, but if it’s only a couple pages I’d still check the boring stuff first. Had one last month where two affiliate pages tanked for like 4 days and it turned out Google had quietly swapped the canonicals around after some internal link changes. No obvious GSC drama, of course, because why would that be useful. If those pages are still indexed, I’d look at: – whether they’re getting hit less from internal links – if the canonical changed on you – whether some other URL is outranking the page you actually want – server logs if you’ve got them, just to see if Google’s even bothering to crawl If it’s a sitewide thing, then sure, maybe it’s one of Google’s usual little mood swings. But “same content, same plugins” doesn’t mean much anymore. Google can still decide one page looks “less helpful” for no reason that makes…
