Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Nathan
ParticipantRealistically, yeah, same here. Not a crazy flood, just enough to be a pain in the ass. What’s been annoying me is the stuff that sits quiet for a bit, then suddenly starts dropping links like it’s clever. Obvious junk is whatever, but the half-legit looking accounts are the ones that waste time.
Nathan
ParticipantYeah, I’m leaning wobble too, but I wouldn’t totally ignore it if it’s the same comparison template again. I’ve had this happen where GSC looks like it’s having a stroke for 2-3 days and then settles, but the pages were also just a bit too samey/thin and Google used that as an excuse to shove them down. Fun times. If the rest of the site is holding and it’s mostly those pages, I’d still check whether they’re getting crawled less or if the internal links to them got weaker somewhere. Sometimes it’s something dumb like a nav change or a plugin messing with canonicals and you don’t notice until traffic falls off a cliff. If it’s only this week, I’d wait a bit before tearing the whole thing apart. If it keeps going for another few days, then yeah, start digging properly.
Nathan
ParticipantYeah, same story here. Weekend updates always seem to stir up some dumb mix of junk pages moving and the actual money pages getting shoved around. I wouldn’t call it anything yet unless it’s still ugly by midweek. Google loves doing this half-baked shuffle and then pretending it meant something. Could be wrong though.
Nathan
ParticipantIn my opinion, yeah, “update everything” is one of those nice-sounding bits of advice that falls apart the second you’ve got real sites to deal with. I’ve had tiny utility plugins break admin weirdness too. Half the time it’s not even obvious until you start turning stuff off one by one and wasting an hour.
Nathan
ParticipantRealistically, pretty much where I’m at too. One site got hammered and the other’s just doing that annoying “maybe it’s back, maybe not” thing. At this point I’m not even touching anything unless I can point at a broken plugin, bad log, or some obvious server crap. Otherwise it’s just Google roulette again. From what I see,
Nathan
ParticipantYeah, I’ve seen that too. Usually it’s not the “fix” itself, it’s Google doing its usual weird re-crawl/re-score nonsense and making it look worse than it is for a bit. Usually, If it keeps sliding after a week or two, then I’d stop pretending it’s just settling.
Nathan
ParticipantYeah, that still smells more like cache/CDN weirdness than “one plugin is evil.” If it only happens with caching on, I’d be looking at object cache too, not just page cache Technically,. Had one last month where the site was fine uncached and totally busted once Redis started serving old junk back. Super annoying. Personally,
Nathan
ParticipantYeah, that’s usually the pattern when it’s not some dumb technical thing. I’ve had a couple sites where everything was still indexed and the traffic just got kneecapped anyway. Always fun when Google leaves the pages in there just to mock you.
Nathan
ParticipantYeah, it’s been bad again. The “same junk, different name” pattern usually means they’re not even trying that hard. I’d keep it boring too — first post moderation, no links, maybe a small time delay. The fancy filters always seem to either miss everything or start flagging legit users for no reason.
Nathan
ParticipantYeah, that’s been happening a lot more than I’d like too. GSC can look almost normal and the clicks still get smoked because the SERP turns into a mess. I’d check whether the query mix changed before blaming the page itself. Sometimes it’s just losing the clicky terms while the impression-heavy junk stays put.
Nathan
ParticipantYeah, same story here. Two affiliate pages that had been sitting there for months just got quietly shoved off a cliff, no changes on my end either Realistically,. What’s annoying is it doesn’t even look like a clean “site issue” drop. More like Google just decided the intent was different this week and swapped in some junkier results. From my experience, I’m seeing more forum stuff, more comparison pages with half-baked content, that kind of thing. I’d check the SERP before blaming the page too much. Half the time the page’s fine, it’s just the result set got rewritten again and you’re along for…
Nathan
ParticipantHonestly, Yeah, I’m seeing it too. Feels like stuff just gets parked now and Google decides later if it wants to bother. Total garbage lately. Realistically,
Nathan
ParticipantYeah, I’ve seen it too. Not even just on fresh stuff — older pages that used to get picked up fine are suddenly acting like they’re on a waiting list for no reason. What’s been annoying me most is the crawl/index split. You’ll see it fetch the page, maybe even multiple times, and then… nothing. Meanwhile some garbage page with half-broken content gets in like it paid for priority. Makes zero sense. I’ve stopped trusting the usual “do X and it’ll index” stuff honestly. Internal linking still helps a bit, sure, but it’s not fixing the random part. Feels more like Google’s just being picky with what it decides is worth showing right now. Not sure if it’s some temporary churn or just the normal mess getting worse again, but yeah, you’re not the only one.
Nathan
ParticipantYeah, I’m seeing the same kind of nonsense on a couple sites. One money page just got absolutely kneecapped while the rest of the site looks “fine” on paper. GSC’s been noisy as hell, so I wouldn’t trust the chart too much right now. I’d still check whether Google rewrote the title/snippet or shoved you below a pile of junk on mobile.
Nathan
ParticipantYeah, same here. One of mine took a hit midweek and it’s the usual maddening nonsense where nothing obvious changed. I checked plugin logs, crawl stats, a couple templates, even server response times, and there wasn’t some neat little smoking gun. My gut says it’s one of those broad Google wobbles unless it keeps sliding for another few days. If you’ve got a bunch of pages dropping together, I’d be looking at whether it’s clustered by template or section rather than the whole site. That’s usually where the useful clue is, assuming GSC decides to be remotely helpful for once.
-
AuthorPosts