Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
From my experience, yeah, I’d be wary of calling it an “update” too fast. If GSC’s mostly flat and it’s just clicks/CTR getting weird, that’s usually SERP junk, title rewrites, or some layout change on Google’s side. I’ve had pages look “fine” in rankings and still get kneecapped on traffic because the snippet got mangled or the result dropped lower on the page without the position chart really screaming about it. That said, if it’s a bunch of pages at once, I’d still check for one shared thing before blaming Google. Same template, same title pattern, same internal linking, same intent cluster… usually one of those is off. Den’s “it’s just your site” take is a bit too lazy for my taste, but yeah, sometimes it is something dumb on our end. That’s been my experience anyway.
Yeah, I wouldn’t call that “just Google being weird” either. If GA’s still showing sessions but leads dropped, that’s usually some mix of crawl weirdness, bot blocking, or a quiet conversion tracking issue nobody wants to look at. After a host move I’ve seen Googlebot get slowed down by WAF rules more times than I can count. I’d be checking server logs and response times before touching titles or content. The crawl delay part especially makes me think the new host is either a bit sluggish or throwing up some nonsense for bots.
Yeah, same old garbage here too. I’ve been seeing a pretty clear uptick in junk signups the last few days, nothing fancy, just enough to be a pain in the ass. I’d tighten regs a bit if it keeps going, but yeah, that usually means some legit people moaning about “too many steps” right after. Never win. That’s how I look at it.
Personally, yeah, I’m seeing some of that too. One site’s basically flat on rankings but the clicks fell off hard, which usually means the SERP changed more than the site did. Google’s been doing that annoying thing where the result still looks “okay” in Search Console, but the actual click demand gets kneecapped. Titles getting rewritten, more junk above the fold, AI crap, whatever they’re calling it this week. I’d be looking at query-level drops, not the homepage graph. If it’s mostly a couple of pages or a few money terms, that’s probably where the damage is.
Realistically, yeah, same pattern here. It’s not even a clean “everything dropped” kind of hit, just the money pages getting shoved down while the fluff hangs on for dear life. I’ve seen this before and it usually ends up being some dumb selective reassessment, not a sitewide disaster. Doesn’t make it less annoying though. If it’s the same pages that keep getting hammered every update, I’d be looking at intent mismatch or whatever nonsense they’re weighting this round, not links or technical stuff first.
Yeah, I’ve seen a bit of that this week too. Not a total faceplant, just enough of a click drop to be annoying while the rank tracker pretends everything’s fine. Usually when it’s like that, I don’t trust the rankings chart much. Google can reshuffle the SERP junk around you and your position looks “stable” while CTR gets kneecapped. I’d check GSC by device and query type first. Some of my affiliate pages get hit harder on mobile for no obvious reason, and sometimes it’s just a couple of money terms getting worse snippets than usual. If impressions are holding but clicks are down, I’d lean SERP/layout stuff before site issue. If both are off, then yeah, maybe there’s something broader going…
Yeah, I’ve seen that too. Feels less like a clean “hit” and more like Google just shuffling the deck again. If the page is still ranking-ish but clicks died, I’d suspect SERP junk before anything dramatic. GSC’s been a mess for weeks anyway. Could be wrong though.
Yeah, I’ve seen that. Usually it’s Google poking at a bunch of URLs, deciding half of them are garbage, then the whole thing gets a bit wobbly for a few days. If it was a real burst on actual pages and not some tag/filter nonsense, I’d be looking at crawl logs and canonicals before I blamed the update fairy. Google’s been doing this weird “index first, think later” thing a lot lately.
In most cases, yeah, same here. Feels like the usual Google mess where the positions look “okay” and the clicks just vanish anyway. I’d be looking at SERP changes before blaming the page itself. Just my experience.
Yeah, seeing the same thing on a couple sites. What’s weird is it’s not even the ugly pages half the time — just random clean URLs sitting there forever while some junk gets indexed fast. Googlebot seems to hit the usual stuff and then disappear like it got bored. I’ve stopped assuming “discovered” means anything useful anymore. Half the time it feels like crawl budget / prioritization roulette, not a content issue. In my opinion,
Realistically, yeah, I’m seeing the same mess. What’s annoying is it doesn’t even look like a clean “new pages are slow” situation anymore — it’s like Google’s picking random crap to trust first. I’ve had decent WP pages sit there with proper internal links and sitemap entries, then some thin junk page gets crawled and indexed almost immediately. Makes no sense. I’ve checked the usual stuff too: sitemap submission, crawl stats, internal linking, noindex accidents, canonical weirdness. Nothing obvious. One thing I did notice on a couple sites was that pages buried a bit deeper in the structure are taking way longer than they used to, even when the homepage is getting crawled fine. So maybe discovery is part of it, but that still doesn’t explain the garbage pages getting a free pass. Honestly feels like another one of those periods where Google’s just being inconsistent for no good reason. I’m not calling it a site issue first either.
Honestly, Yeah, I’m seeing the same kind of garbage on one client site. Nothing changed, no tech issues, and GSC’s being annoyingly vague as usual. At this point I’m leaning more toward SERP shuffling / intent weirdness than an actual site problem. Google loves doing that thing where it looks like “rankings are fine” and then clicks just quietly fall off a cliff anyway. Could be wrong though.
Yeah, I’m seeing it too, and it’s been extra dumb lately. Fresh pages just sit there forever, then some crap page I didn’t even care about gets picked up like it’s important. I’ve stopped assuming crawl means anything useful now. That’s been my experience anyway.
Yeah, it’s been ugly here too. I don’t think it’s “just your forum” — feels like the usual bot junk is ramping up again.
Yeah, I’d still put money on the plugin update before I’d blame Google for this. If it was right after the update, that timing’s too neat to ignore. I’ve had stuff like this where the site *looked* fine but the output changed just enough to screw with crawlers or caching. Sometimes it’s not even the plugin you think it is, it’s the one that hooks into it. I’d roll back the last update and check if the weird clicks settle down. If they do, there’s your answer, annoying as it is.