Traffic dropped after indexing finally worked

[pixelwitch]

Realistically, anyone else had this happen? I’ve got pages that sat ignored for weeks, then suddenly Google indexes them… and the traffic just dies anyway. It’s like great, thanks, now you can see my content while also deciding it’s garbage. I’m seeing it on a couple affiliate sites, not just one. Curious if anyone else has had the same weird “indexed but useless” thing lately Honestly,.

[Nathan]

Yeah, I’ve seen that too. Indexed doesn’t mean much anymore if Google decides the page is thin or just not worth showing. Had a couple WP affiliate sites do exactly that — pages finally get picked up, then impressions just sit there or tank after a week or two. Usually it’s either weak intent match, some template issue, or the site’s just getting treated like another cookie-cutter affiliate dump. Google’s real generous like that. From what I see,

[Nathan]

Personally, yeah, that’s been happening a lot more than it used to. I’ve had pages sit dead for ages, finally get indexed, then basically get buried the moment Google “notices” them. Usually means they passed the crawl/index hurdle but still aren’t earning anything in the actual SERPs. Which is almost worse, honestly. On affiliate sites especially, I’ve seen it where the page gets indexed, gets a tiny burst, then falls off a cliff. Feels like Google’s just testing it, deciding it’s another samey affiliate page, and moving on. Annoying as hell. From what I see,

[Pike]

Yeah, I’ve had that too. Indexed feels like a fake win half the time — page finally shows up, then Google just kinda shrugs and buries it. Usually for me it’s a sign the page got through the doorway but didn’t pass whatever dumb quality check they’re doing that week. On affiliate stuff especially, it’s brutal.

[Pike]

I mean, yeah, pretty much. Indexed just means Google bothered to look at it, not that it actually wants to send anything. I’ve had a few pages do the same thing — sit forever, then once they finally show up they get like 3 impressions and die. Usually means the page cleared crawl/index but got nowhere in the actual SERPs. Brutal.

[Author]

Posts