- This topic has 6 replies, 5 voices, and was last updated 20 hours, 50 minutes ago by
.
-
Posts
-
-
To be fair, not even kidding, I fixed a bunch of stupid stuff on one of my niche sites last week — cleaned up some broken links, removed a couple junk plugins, tightened the theme a bit — and now the thing feels like it got punished for it. I know correlation isn’t causation or whatever, but this happens to me way too often. I’ll leave a messy site alone for months and it limps along. Then I actually try to improve it and Google acts like I broke the whole thing. Search Console is showing impressions down, clicks down, and one of my main money pages dropped like 8 spots basically overnight. No manual action, no obvious crawl issue, nothing. Just… dead. I’ve got another site where the AI-written stuff is still floating around strangely enough, while the “better” edited posts are the ones getting nowhere. Makes me wonder if I’m wasting my time polishing these things at all. Anyone else seeing weird drops after site cleanup lately? Or am I just getting slapped for touching anything again?
-
Yeah, I’ve had that happen too. Clean up a site and suddenly it feels like Google goes “oh cool, let’s punish this guy for trying.” Could be coincidence, could be the site was already hanging by a thread and the changes just lined up with the drop. Still annoying as hell either way. I’ve definitely seen junky old posts survive while the “better” ones just sit there doing nothing, so I wouldn’t assume the cleanup itself fixed or broke anything.
-
Could just be timing, honestly. Fixing a site doesn’t mean Google suddenly rewards it, and half the time the drop was already brewing before u touched anything. Still, if it was one of those “cleaned up a bunch at once” jobs, I’d be looking at what changed the most, not the cleanup itself. The AI junk floating while the edited stuff sinks is pretty normal garbage at this point, annoying as hell but not…
-
Realistically, from what I’ve seen, yeah, I’ve seen that too many times to call it a coincidence every single time. Usually when I’ve had a “cleanup” and then the site tanks, it was either: – I changed too much at once – the site was already weak and the timing just made it obvious – Google was relying on some ugly internal signal and I accidentally disturbed it The annoying part is the junkier pages hanging around while the actually edited stuff goes nowhere. That part feels backwards as hell, but honestly it’s not that rare. If Den’s gonna jump in with the usual “timing bro” thing, in most cases, sure, but I’d still want to know what kind of cleanup it was. Some of these sites are basically held together by bad structure and dumb internal linking, and when you “fix” it you can sometimes just remove the weird little crutches it was living on.
-
Yeah, I’d look hard at what got changed all at once before blaming the cleanup itself. If you touched a bunch of internal links, plugins, and theme stuff in one go, that’s enough to shake things up for a bit. Not saying Google “punished” it, just that you probably moved a few signals around at the same time and now it’s sorting itself out. What I’d check first: – did any important pages lose internal links? – did canonical / noindex / robots stuff get weird after the theme tweak? – did the junk plugin removal break some output or schema? – did the main money page change title/H1/content enough to matter? The AI junk hanging around while the edited stuff does nothing is annoying, but yeah, that’s not exactly shocking anymore. I’ve seen cleaner pages stall while ugly old ones keep breathing for no good reason. If you want, post what actually changed on the money page and I can tell you what looks most suspicious.
-
In my opinion, yeah, I’ve had that happen too. Usually it’s not the cleanup itself so much as you yanked a few crutches out at once and Google takes its sweet time figuring out what’s left. The part that bugs me is the ugly AI crap surviving while the better pages get smacked. Seen that enough to not be shocked anymore, unfortunately. That’s how I look at it.
-
Personally, yeah, I’ve seen that too. Usually it’s not “cleanup = penalty,” it’s more like you changed enough stuff at once that the site’s signals got shuffled and Google’s being dumb about it for a while. The part with the junk AI pages hanging around while the better stuff drops is annoying as hell, but I’ve had that same nonsense happen. If you changed internal links and the theme at the same time, I’d be looking there first.
-
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.